In recent years, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has advanced at an astonishing pace, sparking debates between two distinct camps with strong convictions. Although I have not used AI to create my photographs, I’ve explored the concepts behind this technology and conducted research to better understand its impact on photography. AI has introduced powerful tools for photo editing, enhancing artistic expression and improving the viewer’s experience. This evolution mirrors the traditional darkroom techniques where photographers would manipulate images through processes like burning, dodging, or etching. This raises a key question in the debate: Is AI simply a modern extension of past darkroom editing, or does it represent a form of “fake” photography?

​

AI has undeniably streamlined photo editing, significantly reducing the time required for tasks that once took hours. Routine processes can be automated, and complex edits, such as sky replacements or color adjustments, are now accessible to photographers of all skill levels. What previously demanded expensive equipment and extensive expertise can now be achieved by beginners, democratizing the art of photography. As a photographer, I appreciate exploring new concepts and experimenting with innovative techniques. I can see how AI-generated images can be viewed as art, similar to painting a scene from imagination. For instance, recreating a sunset using AI can be likened to painting that sunset, capturing the creative vision of the artist.

​

However, there are drawbacks. Some argue that AI diminishes the craftsmanship involved in traditional photography. The effort to perfect lighting, angles, and styles is now simplified, potentially leading to an overreliance on technology and a decline in the skill and intimate understanding that seasoned photographers cherish. AI also challenges the authenticity and originality of photography. Edited images can become unrecognizable from their original form, blurring the line between reality and artificiality. This shift may undermine the core values of traditional photography and could lead to market saturation, devaluing professional work. As AI technology becomes more widespread, distinguishing between amateur and professional efforts grows increasingly difficult, complicating the justification of professional rates and valuations. Moreover, the rise of AI in photography brings ethical concerns, particularly regarding the truthfulness of images in an era where deepfakes and altered realities are common. This further complicates the public’s trust in the authenticity of photographs.

​

In summary, AI technology in photography presents a mix of significant benefits and notable challenges. While I personally choose not to use this technology in my work, I can appreciate both perspectives — the arguments that justify its use and the concerns that it raises in our increasingly digital world. On one hand, AI tools have made photo editing more accessible, efficient, and capable of producing stunning results that were once difficult to achieve. This democratization of photography allows more people to engage with the art form and explore their creative potential.

However, this shift also introduces complexities. The boundary between AI-generated images and traditional professional photography is becoming increasingly blurred, making it harder to distinguish between the two. This raises questions about the nature of “professional work” and what it means to be a professional photographer in a world where advanced tools can automate much of the creative process.

​

Despite these challenges, it’s important to recognize that, whether created through traditional methods or with the help of AI, all these images can be appreciated as forms of art. Art, after all, is about expression and interpretation, and AI-generated works offer new avenues for creativity and innovation. Yet, as we embrace these new tools, we must also reflect on the evolving definition of photography and maintain a balance that respects both traditional craftsmanship and modern advancements.